I think I'm a bit behind the times in posting on this update to the console version of Battlefield 3, but I needed to weigh in on it today due to the amount of BF3 that I played, or rather tried to play, over the weekend.
For those of you that don't know, the Rent-A-Server update basically took all of the servers that were publicly hosted and placed them on a list for private users to rent and use as they see fit. So for x amount of Microsoft Points you can rent a server, that you customize the games on, for a day, week, or month. This is a great deal for anyone that wants to shell out the money to play the game they already paid for, but for the rest of us it blows.
The first time that I attempted to do a quick match to get back into playing BF3, I ended up on a server with a description of, "snipes or pilots only." When I spawned as an Engineer I was immediately booted. To avoid this type of garbage I was able to go into the Server Browser and pick and choose what I wanted to play there, but with a controller that takes about 15 minutes and feels like a waste of my time. I want to be able to jump into the game and play within ten minutes, not look around for a server that I'm going to be able to tolerate.
A few other issues that I've had with people and their servers are games having too many tickets and lasting too long, no variations in maps, and a lack of players. When a game has 900 tickets the game is just unbearable. After the first half hour, you're weeping to just have the thing finish. You'd leave, but then you'd have wasted that much time for no points. Even if you're dominating the match, the amount of tickets that owning all of the capture points bleeds from the other team is too minuscule to speed up the end. Combine that with playing the same map over and over, because you don't want to leave a decent server that won't kick you for no reason, and you end up with a pile of shit.
Finally, the lack of players on some servers is disturbing. I started a few games where it was just me and my friend, and some where it was just me. I think that the lack of players just sums up how awful this whole update experience has been. Like myself, I would bet that most players are getting fed up with how this whole game has been handled. If the servers are going to continue to be set up like this, Battlefield 3 is going to suffer a huge lack of me, not to mention other people that are pissed off at the changes.